Phoenix/ Crime & Emergencies
AI Assisted Icon
Published on May 10, 2024
"Gilbert Goons" Gang Pleads Not Guilty in Brutal Slaying of Teen, Trial Date May Drag to 2025Source: Unsplash / Michael Fortsch

Seven young men charged with the brutal murder and kidnapping of 16-year-old Preston Lord appeared in court on Thursday, stirring the ongoing community dialogue around youth violence. William Hines, Talyn Vigil, Taylor Sherman, Dominic Turner, Treston Billey, Talan Renner, and Jacob Meisner, allegedly part of a newly classified criminal street gang known as the "Gilbert Goons," were implicated in the Oct. 28 assault during a Halloween party in Queen Creek, as reported by FOX 10 Phoenix.

With all seven pleading not guilty, the defense argued that they may not be ready to proceed to trial until at least 2025, given the enormity of the evidence. Judge Bruce R. Cohen set a tentative trial start for July 21, 2025, albeit subject to change. During the hearing, Renner's lawyer was vehemently opposed to having media cameras in the courtroom, expressing concern over the potential to taint future jurors. "I feel like I have a 50-caliber weapon pointed at me," said the attorney in the courtroom, a sentiment obtained by Arizona's Family.

The city where the crime was committed, Chandler, is also moving to prevent future violence. On Thursday night, the Chandler City Council was scheduled to vote on two ordinances: one to criminalize minors from possessing brass knuckles, and another to hold parents or guardians responsible for disorderly gatherings involving juveniles at their properties. These legislative developments follow the resolution adopted earlier this year by Chandler to actively pursue measures to curb youth violence.

As the community processes the implications of the crime, legal experts cast doubt on the trial's tentative start date. "That seems fast for a murder trial with a huge number of defendants," Louis Fidel, a criminal defense attorney not involved in the case, told Arizona's Family. He alluded to the possible advantages that delays could pose for the defense, such as diminished witness recollections and a decline in case notoriety. Meanwhile, the prosecution stands before the considerable task of potentially changing the scheduled trial date, against the backdrop of a community still grappling with the loss suffered and the desire for justice in the wake of such a heinous act.

Lord's death, resulting from his injuries two days post-assault, has since propelled the "Gilbert Goons" into the harsh spotlight of legal classification as a criminal street gang. With additional charges pertaining to other violent acts pending against Meisner and Hines, the case has become a crucible for examining the reach and response to teen violence in the East Valley community.